Hong Kong Faces Western Criticism Over Beijing-Backed Security Law
Summary from the AllSides News Team
The Chinese government pushed back on Wednesday against criticism of Hong Kong’s newly passed national security law, which includes provisions for life imprisonment for crimes such as treason and insurrection.
The Details: The law's unanimous passage comes two years after Beijing imposed a sweeping national security law in the city following protests in 2019. Notably, local legislation indicates it could also apply to those living outside the city's borders. The European Union and United Nations have expressed deep concern about the bill's potential impact on residents' rights and freedoms.
Key Quotes: Commenting on the new legislation, Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesperson Lin Jian stated, “We strongly deplore and firmly oppose individual countries and organizations’ slandering and smear against the Safeguarding National Security Bill of Hong Kong.”
For Context: A previous attempt to pass similar legislation ("Article 23") failed in 2003 following mass protests. The push to pass the recent legislation limited the public consultation period to one month, in contrast to three months for the 2003 bill.
How the Media Covered It: Coverage in American media often highlighted critics of the law and used negative language; NBC News (Lean Left bias) said the law “aims to ensnare” people. Business media outlets highlighted concerns over the city's
“role as financial hub.” However, the editors of the South China Morning Post (Center bias), an English-language Hong Kong-based newspaper, praised the law’s passage as “long overdue” and providing a “clearer direction.” This summary was developed with the help of AllSides' AI technology.
Featured Coverage of this Story
From the Left
China pushes back on international criticism of restrictive new Hong Kong law
China hit back Wednesday against international criticism of a new national security law passed in Hong Kong, dismissing concerns that it will further erode civil liberties in the Chinese territory.
The United States and other governments have expressed opposition to the legislation, known as Article 23, which Hong Kong lawmakers passed unanimously Tuesday night after deliberating at record speed.
“We strongly deplore and firmly oppose individual countries and organizations’ slandering and smear against the Safeguarding National Security Bill of Hong Kong,” Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesperson Lin Jian said at a regular news briefing in...
From the Center
Article 23 reaction: US and Britain criticise ‘incredibly vague’ new Hong Kong national security law
The US and British governments on Tuesday criticised Hong Kong for its passage of a new domestic national security law, claiming the measure was rushed and that vague language in its provisions created uncertainty for some of the city’s residents.
While they stopped short of announcing any immediate countermeasures, the US State Department said it was “analysing” the law to understand what risks were involved for American citizens and Britain suggested it might put diplomats on shaky ground.
Hong Kong lawmakers unanimously passed Hong Kong’s domestic national security law just hours earlier, at the...
From the Right
UK, EU Condemn Hong Kong’s New National Security Law
The UK and the European union on Tuesday condemned Hong Kong’s new rubber-stamped national security law, saying it would further erode freedoms in the financial hub and may affect diplomatic missions.
British Foreign Secretary Lord Cameron said the law will “have far-reaching implications” for Hong Kong residents, including foreign diplomats, and “enable the continuing erosion of freedoms of speech, of assembly, and of the media.”
The European Union also criticised the law, raising concerns over its “sweeping provisions and broad definitions.”
In statements issued on Wednesday, Beijing’s foreign affairs representative...
AllSides Picks
July 5th, 2024
July 5th, 2024
July 3rd, 2024
More News about China from the Left, Center and Right
From the Left
From the Center
From the Right
