Assange's Plea Deal: Press Freedom Victory or National Security Tragedy?
Summary from the AllSides News Team
What does WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange’s plea deal mean for press freedoms and national security?
From the Right: Noah Rothman (Lean Right bias) argued the U.S. is “surrendering,” deeming it a tragedy that “Assange will not face American justice.” Arguing the leaked documents “outed the Afghans who worked directly with American servicemen, opening them up to retribution,” Rothman concluded Assange’s work was not journalistic but “akin to the conduct we would expect from a hostile intelligence network.”
From the Center: Matt Taibbi (Center bias) concluded the terms of the plea deal “means this will remain a sword over the heads of anyone reporting on national security issues.” Taibbi argued, “Although coverage today focuses on solicitation of classified documents about the Iraq and Afghanistan wars whose publication supposedly ‘endangered lives,’ the Justice Department made it clear from the start that its fury centered on efforts to disclose governmental bad behavior.”
From the Left: A writer in The Guardian (Lean Left bias) deemed it “a day to celebrate, but also one to demand answers. Why – why, for heaven’s sake – has it taken so long?” The writer concluded, “We have not heard the last of the Julian Assange story. He must now be allowed to catch his breath, and we can celebrate that he is no longer in the dungeon. Let’s hope there are at least some politicians who will take note, and have the courage in the future to stand up to bullies rather than just mouth platitudes about free speech.”
Featured Coverage of this Story
From the Left
Julian Assange’s release frees up one UK prison cell, but why has it taken so long – and what about the others?Finally. After more than five years locked inside HMP Belmarsh, Britain’s most secure prison, and seven years confined to the Ecuadorian embassy in London, Julian Assange can breathe some fresh, free air. It is certainly a day to celebrate, but also one to demand answers. Why – why, for heaven’s sake – has it taken so long? And what about all the others who languish in crazily overcrowded British jails?
It seems appropriate that Assange’s release, on the basis of a deal that gives the US government the fig leaf...
From the Center
Assange is Free, But Never Forget How the Press Turned on HimWikileaks founder Julian Assange is free, having struck a deal with the United States Justice Department that will credit him for time served and allow him to go home. As someone who campaigned against his detention, I’m happy for him, his wife Stella, his brother Gabriel Shipton, and the other members of his inner circle who kept the case in the public eye all these years. They deserve to celebrate today.
Despite the fact that the plea was carefully crafted to say the state never proved its case, the Justice...
From the Right
Julian Assange’s Plea Deal Is a TragedyJoe Biden’s Justice Department has elected to resolve a decade-long standoff with WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange by surrendering.
On Monday, Assange agreed to travel to Saipan — an American outpost in the Pacific close to his native Australia — where he will plead guilty to a single felony count of illegally obtaining and disclosing classified documents. There, Assange is expected to be sentenced to the time he has already served in a British prison following his forcible removal from a London-based Ecuadorian embassy in 2019. Save this exercise in process,...
AllSides Picks
June 28th, 2024
June 28th, 2024