Supreme Court to Rule on Law Banning Transgender Surgeries for Minors
Summary from the AllSides News Team
The Supreme Court will for the first time deliberate on a state’s attempt to limit transgender medical treatments for minors.
Details: The case, originating in Tennessee, could impact similar laws in over 20 states. The justices will hear the case this year, with a decision likely coming in 2025. The Tennessee law restricts puberty blockers, hormone therapy, and surgery for minors, which the Department of Justice and Tennessee families have challenged. The DOJ argued in court documents that, without Supreme Court review, families might lose essential medical care. The Supreme Court will address whether such state laws infringe on the 14th Amendment’s equal protection clause.
For Context: Republican-majority state legislatures have increasingly sought to limit transgender procedures for minors, a contentious issue within the overall national discussion on transgender rights. While supporters of such laws argue they protect minors from irreversible, life-altering decisions, opponents believe they infringe upon essential healthcare rights for transgender youth.
How the Media Covered It: Left-rated outlets more often referred to the procedures as “gender-affirming care,” while right-rated outlets more often referred to them as “transgender procedures,” illustrating the partisan divide regarding whether the procedures are essential or not. The Raw Story (Left bias) framed the issue as concerning the fundamental freedom to access vital healthcare. The Washington Examiner (Lean Right bias) noted that the DOJ’s position on the issues could change if former President Donald Trump retakes the White House in November. This summary was developed with the help of AllSides' AI technology.
Featured Coverage of this Story
From the Left
Supreme Court to address state restrictions on gender-affirming careThe Supreme Court announced Monday that it will consider state laws blocking gender-affirming care in young people.
The High Cout announced that it will address challenges to the Tennessee law that bans puberty blockers, hormone therapy and surgery for minors, NBC revealed in breaking news.
Earlier this year, the court allowed a similar law in Idaho to be enforced in part, NBC News reported at the time.
Conservative Justice Neil Gorsuch wrote in the Idaho opinion that a lower court's decision had put the whole law on hold, which he...
From the Center
US Supreme Court to hear challenge to ban on transgender care for minorsThe U.S. Supreme Court agreed on Monday to decide the legality of a Republican-backed ban in Tennessee on gender-affirming medical care for transgender minors, as the justices waded into another contentious issue implicating LGBT rights.
They took up an appeal by Democratic President Joe Biden's administration of a lower court's decision upholding Tennessee's ban on medical treatments including hormones and surgeries for minors experiencing gender dysphoria. The court will hear the case in its next term, which begins in October.
The challengers contend that banning care for transgender youth violates...
From the Right
Supreme Court to hear challenge to Tennessee ban on child transgender proceduresThe Supreme Court agreed on Monday to take up a challenge by the Biden administration to a Tennessee law that restricts transgender procedures for minors.
The decision to hear the case United States v. Skrmetti marks the first time the high court will rule on matters arising from the major culture war battle over transgender medical treatments for children. The Tennessee law in question restricts puberty blockers, hormone therapy, and surgery for minors.
Gov. Bill Lee (R-TN) signed the bill into law in March, and the Department of Justice filed suit against the measure...
AllSides Picks
June 28th, 2024
June 27th, 2024
June 26th, 2024
June 28th, 2024