'Border Czar'? Kamala Harris' Record on Immigration
Summary from the AllSides News Team
As GOP leaders made immigration a key focus of the Republican National Convention, convention speakers frequently noted Vice President Kamala Harris’ border policy and described her as a “border czar.”
For Context: Axios (Lean Left bias) received criticism Wednesday for reporting that Republicans inaccurately dubbed Harris as a “border czar,” when the outlet described Harris as such in a 2021 article.
Harris’s Record: In 2021, Biden asked Harris to lead efforts to address the causes of immigration in El Salvador, Guatemala, and Honduras. Harris worked with Central American leaders to reduce drug and weapons smuggling and corruption, provide humanitarian relief and add economic opportunities. She hasn’t been to the border or the countries below it since early 2022, however.
How the Media Covered It: Media across the spectrum noted that Harris was directed to focus on Central American countries, not to lead immigration policy overall. Many also noted her sparse record after receiving that assignment. NBC News (Lean Left) said Harris’s “public-facing work on addressing the root causes of migration largely evaporated within months.” Conversely, Time Magazine (Lean Left) argued that Harris’s efforts won’t bear immediate results, and that she became “the most visible scapegoat” for the border crisis as the number of crossings increased. Sources from the right often noted Harris’ border “failures,” including the record numbers of illegal border crossings seen in recent years.
Featured Coverage of this Story
From the Left
Kamala Harris Was Never Biden’s ‘Border Czar.’ Here’s What She Really DidOn her first foreign trip as Vice President in June 2021, Kamala Harris was tasked with delivering a blunt message in Guatemala City. "I want to be clear to folks in this region who are thinking about making that dangerous trek to the United States-Mexico border: Do not come," she said at a press conference, pausing for effect. "Do not come."
Three years later, that sound bite may come to haunt Harris' nascent presidential campaign. Despite her warning, border crossings reached historic highs during the Biden Administration. Republican critics cast...
From the Right
Kamala Harris told migrants ‘do not come’ to US — and 8 million showed up anyway: Inside the veep’s legacy as ‘border czar’Kamala Harris told migrants “do not come” to the US, but at least 8 million came anyway.
In perhaps her most famous speech as vice president, which she made in June 2021 after she was given responsibility for securing the US border, Harris tried to convince migrants to stop flooding into the US in the wake of President Biden’s 2020 election victory.
“I want to be clear to folks in this region who are thinking about making that dangerous trek to the United States-Mexico border, do not come. Do not come,” she...
From the Center
Immigration group says Kamala Harris has record to fight GOP's criticismRepublicans were quick to call out what they saw as a lack of action on the U.S.-Mexico border by Vice President Kamala Harris, following her endorsement by President Biden to be the Democrat nominee, but at least one immigration group is confident she can take on the GOP's top issue.
The Immigration Hub (TIH), a nonprofit immigrant advocacy group, told Newsweek that Harris' work as attorney general and then senator from California — in which her office tackled international criminal gangs while also making legal immigration pathways easier — meant she could counter Donald Trump's policies....
AllSides Picks
September 12th, 2024
September 13th, 2024