Judge Rejects Trump’s Request to Move Hush Money Case to Federal Court
Summary from the AllSides News Team
A federal judge in Manhattan rejected a request by former President Donald Trump to move his hush money case to a federal court on Tuesday.
The Details: Trump had requested to move the case through claims that New York’s court system was biased against him and did not adequately consider the Supreme Court’s recent presidential immunity ruling. Judge Alvin Hellerstein determined that district courts don’t have the jurisdiction to consider Trump’s claims of bias and previously determined that Trump’s hush money payments to adult actress Stormy Daniels do not pertain to “official presidential acts” and therefore should not be considered for immunity.
For Context: In July, the Supreme Court ruled 6-3 that Trump has immunity for “official acts” taken as president but not “unofficial” ones. Trump’s sentencing is currently set for September 18, though last week his lawyers separately requested for it to be postponed. CNN (Lean Left bias) reports that this decision could come “as soon as this week.”
Key Quote: “District Courts may not reverse or modify state judgments, even those containing constitutional infirmities because ‘to do so would be an exercise of appellate jurisdiction,’” Hellerstein wrote in a four-page statement.
How The Media Covered It: The Washington Examiner (Lean Right bias) included context that Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg said he did not oppose a sentencing delay per Trump’s request, while CNN wrote that “prosecutors haven’t opposed” it. The Examiner also included that Bragg’s office objected to Trump’s attempt to refile his request to move to a federal court on Tuesday.
Featured Coverage of this Story
From the Right
Trump blocked from moving hush money case to federal court by judgeA federal judge in Manhattan on Tuesday rejected an effort by former President Donald Trump to remove his criminal hush money case to the federal courts, saying there is “nothing” in the Supreme Court‘s recent immunity decision that should allow for such a move.
“Nothing in the Supreme Court’s opinion affects my previous conclusion that the hush money payments were private, unofficial acts, outside the bounds of executive authority,” wrote U.S. District Judge Alvin K. Hellerstein, a Bill Clinton appointee who denied Trump’s effort to move the case to federal court before it was adjudicated.
From the Center
Judge denies Trump bid to move hush money case to federal courtA federal judge ruled Tuesday that former President Trump may not request to move his hush money criminal case to federal court after failing to show “good cause,” meaning the case will remain in New York state court.
U.S. District Judge Alvin Hellerstein said in a four-page order that the two reasons Trump offered as to why his case should be removed — that New York courts were biased against him and that his trial judge did not adequately review the issue of presidential immunity — fall short.
Hellerstein said that district...
From the Left
Federal judge denies Trump’s request to move hush money case to federal courtA federal judge Tuesday denied Donald Trump’s request to move the New York hush money case to federal court, finding there is nothing in the Supreme Court’s presidential immunity ruling that alters his view of the fact that the payments were “private, unofficial acts.”
Last week, the former president’s attorneys sought to move the state case to federal court, an effort they previously lost, citing the Supreme Court’s decision this summer that granted immunity for some of Trump’s conduct that fell within his official powers. They also urged the judge to postpone Trump’s sentencing, currently set...
AllSides Picks
September 15th, 2024
September 10th, 2024
September 9th, 2024
September 13th, 2024